Can it be music? : The work of John Cage
- eruano2
- Oct 14, 2023
- 2 min read
Updated: Dec 4, 2023
As an artist and performer, I've always had an interest in music. As a kid, I remember staging backseat shows to pop music on long car rides, being the best Cotton Eye Joe dancer at family gatherings, and belting my heart out every day in choir class. However, I always struggled to understand some key components of music. Things such as matching pitch or reading music would often make me feel frustrated and confused, making me believe I was never destined to be a music artist. My recent exposure to the great work of John Cage has shown me how wrong I was.
Within his piece Water Walk, John Cage displays that anything and everything is music. While the nicer-sounding examples of music may be a bit more complicated, music can consist of the noise that comes from basic tasks such as watering a plant. Cage shows that it's not the complexity behind the music, but the passion and intention for making the sound. The simplicity behind this was shocking. It's understandable when one watches the Water Walk video and notices that Cage performs with such a serious intent, making purposeful sounds with the utmost precision, all while the audience is laughing at his work. I questioned how Cage must’ve felt at this, but a deeper thought made me realize his brilliance. The contradiction between his serious intent and the audience’s comedic reception highlights that Cage has successfully used his intent to impact the audience. The sound he made was interesting enough to get a reaction because he made it with purpose and pride, no matter how odd it was. The sound and performance made people think. I can name countless stereotypical music that has done less. In this, I realize that music isn't always about how good it sounds. It's about the impact it has and the perception audiences have of it. It is about the heart and soul that goes into it. This is where the most successful music comes from.
Going forward, I hope to utilize sound within my art. I want to impact people with the noise I create. Whether this is something relating to a harp or a garbage truck, my sound will have an impact. Audio is such an important aspect to consider when it comes to art, one I feel is very forgotten about. I question how Cage’s work would be perceived if the audience in the Water Walk video only got to hear the piece instead of seeing it performed live. He was selling recordings of it after all. I couldn't imagine it having the same impact. Like I said, I found his serious performance to have been a foundation of the general concept. It grounded the piece and gave it character. Without the visualization of the performance, it could all just sound like nonsense.

Photo by Paul Bergen
I think this brings forth the discussion of whether or not something can only be considered art if it is impactful. Is it not okay if something just sounds good? I think at the same time, it is really interesting how some people can take home a completely different meaning from music just because of their differences in cultural backgrounds. I think your analysis has provided a very powerful explanation to why his work is interesting.
Eli - Your reflections on John Cage's 'Water Walk' and its influence on your understanding of music and performance art is profoundly insightful. It challenges conventional perceptions of what constitutes music and art, underscoring the power of intention and impact over traditional technical mastery. Your realization that music is about the effect it has, rather than just its auditory appeal, is a significant takeaway. It made me ponder: How often do we overlook the depth and meaning in art due to preconceived notions of what it should be? Cage's work, as you've described, is a testament to the transformative power of art that challenges norms and evokes thought, regardless of its form. This perspective is incredibly liberating for any artist…